Frank Costello: The Prime Minister of the Underworld (1891 – 1973)

Frank Costello – NCS Mobster of the Month for July 2015


“Other kids are brought up nice and sent to Harvard and Yale. Me? I was brought up like a mushroom.”

Frank Costello – NCS Mobster of the Month for July 2015

Those were the words of Frank Costello, a mob boss who went on to become the Prime Minister of the Underworld thanks to his eye for mixing crime with politics in a way no other mob figure could or would.

This trait would eventually help his influence grow in strength for years to come.


The Partnership with Lucky

Lucky Luciano and Frank had a great partnership, and they both hit it off as friends as well as partners in business.

They first met when Costello was in the Morello gang and Lucky was leading a lower east side Manhattan gang. They soon met with Vito Genovese and Tommy “Three-Finger Brown” Lucchese, Meyer Lansky and Benjamin “Bugsy” Siegel to begin controlling gambling, extortion and narcotic rackets amongst other criminal activities.

During the early part of the 1920’s the Prohibition act had come into force which, for the mob, was a prosperous time. It was Arnold Rothstein that first saw the potential behind the new law, and it was he that helped financially back all bootlegging operations. It was also Rothstein who became a big part in the lives of Costello, Luciano, and the Jewish contingent of Lansky and Siegel. He helped teach them the ropes and mentored them in the ways of conducting business.

After the end of the Castellammarese War, in 1931, the Luciano Crime Family was born with Lucky as the boss, Genovese as underboss, and Costello as consigliere.

This was certainly Costello’s time to shine as he controlled many gambling rackets, which made the family a fortune. In fact, the slot machines alone brought in millions of dollars in profit.


Lucky Goes Down

During the mid-1930’s Lucky was sentenced to 30 – 50 years in jail after special prosecutor Thomas Dewey managed to stick some convictions his way. This meant that Genovese would become acting boss, however a year later he was too indicted, this time for murder so he fled back to Italy to avoid being pinned down.

Lucky, from inside prison, decided then he would make Costello the acting boss, giving him a strong control over the family.

Costello was a successful boss to say the least, and he was well liked by the family as he shared profits and didn’t demand big cuts on his criminal earnings.  Due to his political influence and the money that was being made at that time from the slot machine operation, Costello pulled in a lot of money for the family and was a boss that was really underrated when you see how he performed at the helm.


Conflict with Genovese

After Vito Genovese returned from Italy after the murder charge was dropped through lack of witnesses and prosecutors he looked to take back the family from the hands of Costello.

At the time of his return to the family he was only a caporegime (in charge of street soldiers), which I would imagine would have spurred him on in trying to reclaim the family.

Very slyly, Genovese began to build trust and a rapport with members of the family, especially the soldiers, by helping them out when they needed it the most. This was either by doing them some favours or lending them money with the fact that a favour be returned to him later down the line.

So now you had Genovese who was a ruthless murderer, in charge of murderers, and on the other hand Costello who was more of a business man, in charge of the white collar crime rackets.  Luckily for Costello he was a Commission member which meant that Genovese couldn’t call a hit on Frank, or unseat him as family leader.


Start of the Kefauver Hearings

This is where we start to get into the mind of Frank Costello and what makes him tick. The Kefauver Hearings were conducted by the US Senate in an attempt to uncover the underworld and the criminal rackets they ran. Over 600 mob figures would testify before Congress and this was all aired over the TV channels in the early 1950’s.

In the early 50’s Costello was also one of the most powerful and influential mob bosses but he felt something was missing, he felt that he needed to be respected so booked himself in for psychiatric sessions to solve the problem. The psychiatrist actually told Frank that he should spend more time with “normal people” who were outside the mob environment.

This of course didn’t work as he was blatantly a mafia boss and no genuine respect could be granted to him due to this.

Costello agreed to testify at the hearings but didn’t want his face broadcasted, just his hands. In the interview he didn’t really answer many questions, instead he refused to answer most of them apart from one question which was asked by the committee:

“What have you done for your country Mr. Costello?”

In which Costello replied with:

“Paid my tax!”

In addition, this resulted in some laughs around the courtroom.

Due to the high publicity of this campaign it did put a great deal of pressure on Costello, especially as law enforcement knew more about the man at the helm of the Luciano Crime Family.


Escaping Death

During the mid-50’s one of Costello’s main men chose to leave the US to take refuge in Italy after a prison sentence was hanging over his head if he stayed in the US. The man was Joe Adonis and without him, Costello was open to attack. He only had the powerful Albert Anastasia by his side, someone who Genovese knew he would have to remove in order to get at Costello and reclaim the hot seat.

For someone so violent, Genovese had patiently waited 10 years to attempt a hit on Costello, and that time came in 1957 when Genovese had just left prison.

Genovese had ordered Vincent “Chin” Gigante to assassinate Costello as he was walking to the elevator in the lobby of his Manhattan apartment. As Costello got closer to the elevator Gigante who was behind him shouted out “This is for you Frank!”

Frank then turned around quickly and the bullet somehow managed to scrape across his head from the front around the back to the other side. Gigante thinking he had just killed Costello fled the scene.

Frank was a real lucky guy here, because if Gigante hadn’t spoken out then he would have been killed without a shadow of a doubt, there and then.

As Gigante tried to assassinate a powerful mob boss, he had to face up to a mob trial. Lucky for Gigante, Costello chose not to identify his attacker meaning that Gigante got away with the attempted hit and Frank kept to the Code of Omerta.

Gigante, upon leaving the trial thanked Frank for not identifying him.

This was enough to make Frank step down as boss and hand the family over to Genovese, and as Lucky was still held up in prison he was powerless to stop Genovese. Costello and Genovese came to a deal after recovering from the assassination attempt.

The deal was that Costello handed the family to Genovese in return; Costello would keep his legitimate business interests and gambling operations.

Even though Costello was now just a family solider, he was always looked at as a powerful mob boss, and someone who helped build La Cosa Nostra (Our Thing).


His Later Years

Frank always had his hand in the mafia world, and he still held a lot of influence right up until his death in 1973 at the age of 82.

Some of his old friends such as Carlo Gambino, Meyer Lansky and Tommy Lucchese still paid visits to his penthouse, seeking advice on important Mafia affairs.

At the age of 82, Frank suffered from a heart attack that finished him off, even though he battled for 11 days in the hospital.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating / 5. Vote count:

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Casey McBride

Lead editor at the NCS, Casey was the first blogger to set foot in the Social Club, and is the curator at Uncle Frank's Place, that little corner of the NCS dedicated to the discussion and preservation of the life and times of racketeer Frank Costello. Casey's philosophy is to specialize. "There is simply too much information for one person to know it all." he claims. "That's the beauty of the NCS. We have folks from all walks of life, all with different interests and expertise, and it's growing all the time."
Casey McBride

Talk To Us...