Vote Your Favorite New York Mob Rivalry


[socialpoll id=”2308932″]

Through out the ages there have been many great rivalries. And like a Shakespearian drama, “This thing of ours,” has yielded some of the greatest, hate filled, back stabbing, knock down, dragged out rivalries history has to offer. The NCS wanted to get your opinion on a few of these great standoffs, so we’re having a throw down. This is your chance to cast a vote for the greatest New York rivalry in mob history…

Let’s start things off with a bang…

Joe “the Boss” Masseria vs Salvatore Maranzano

Joe "the Boss" Masseria vs Salvatore Maranzano

The last of the “Mustache Petes,” or old world mafios, their fued caused gangsters to hit the mattresses like no time before. In what would become known as the Castellamarese War, they turned the Big Apple into a shooting gallery, causing business to suffer, and the public to become uneasy. Realizing this was counterproductive, mob legends Charlie Luciano, Frank Costello, and Vito Genovese, along with Meyer Lansky and Ben Seigle, would play both sides of this rivalry; a dangerous game that landed them on Marazano’s rub out list. They took matters into their own hands, ridding themselves of both parties with two legendary hits, sparking the birth of the modern American mob.

Next up we have two mob heavy weights…


Frank Costello vs Vito Genovese

Vito Genovese vs Frank Costello

It was brains against brawn in the largest upheaval in the history of what was known as the Luciano family. Upon returning from Italy, Vito, once the acting boss, was demoted and forced to watch from the sidelines as Frank Costello ran the family. Feeling disrespected, Vito patently waited for an opportunity to unseat “the Prime Minister.” After a failed attempt on his life, ordered by Vito, Costello stepped down from his position as boss, and the family was renamed after Genovese. The rivalry didn’t end there however, and Costello would later get revenge by setting Vito up on a drug trafficking charge. Genovese would spend his remaining days in prison. Notably, this is the only one of our rivalries where both men survived.


John Gotti vs Paul Castellano

John Gotti vs Paul Castellano

Though he was a huge money maker, Paul Castellano lacked street credibility. John Gotti, bitter that his mentor, Aniello Dellacroce, had been passed over as boss of the Gambino family in favor of Castellano, plotted perhaps the most famous rub out in the history of the mob. Big Paul was gunned down in front of Sparks Steakhouse, and Gotti began his infamous run as boss of the Gambino family.

The NCS wants to hear from you. Which of these classic rivalries is your favorite? Cast your vote and let us know your opinion with a comment.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating / 5. Vote count:

Casey McBride

Lead editor at the NCS, Casey was the first blogger to set foot in the Social Club, and is the curator at Uncle Frank's Place, that little corner of the NCS dedicated to the discussion and preservation of the life and times of racketeer Frank Costello. Casey's philosophy is to specialize. "There is simply too much information for one person to know it all." he claims. "That's the beauty of the NCS. We have folks from all walks of life, all with different interests and expertise, and it's growing all the time."
Casey McBride

Talk To Us...